主码流实时预览改走 UDP + 关掉流分析与重排缓冲

主码流走 RTSP over TCP 时,一旦设备发送缓冲/交换队列有排队,延迟只会越堆越高
且永远追不回来(TCP 不丢帧),现场表现就是「越看越慢」。

- Open() 默认低延迟:-rtsp_transport udp,外加
  -analyzeduration 0 -max_delay 0 -reorder_queue_size 0 -avioflags direct
  -fflags nobuffer -flags low_delay -fps_mode passthrough
- 4 秒还收不到帧就杀掉进程、改用 TCP 重开一次(部分网络禁 UDP,
  不能让用户因此看不到画面);重开只做一次,并用 RestartGate 串行化
- 复用键带 |ll 后缀,实时预览与回放(OpenUrl 默认 lowLatency=false)不会串流;
  回放仍走 TCP,因为回放靠时间戳对齐,丢包会算错延迟
- 补两行日志:ffmpeg 实际用的传输方式、首帧耗时(ms)
- README 补齐子码流/主码流两条链路的延迟差异与排查日志

Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
This commit is contained in:
liufumingren 2026-10-23 21:30:29 +08:00
parent 8c83275719
commit 41063761f7
2 changed files with 134 additions and 21 deletions

View File

@ -403,6 +403,28 @@ cd desktop\installer
>
> 端口可用 `YUNCANG_LOCAL_WS_PORT` 覆盖;前端用 `VITE_LOCAL_WS` 覆盖默认 `ws://127.0.0.1:17301/`。
#### 预览延迟(子码流 / 主码流是两条完全不同的链路)
| 码流 | 链路 | 典型延迟 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 子码流(`mode=stream`) | 8000 私有协议 → PlayM4 解码 → 取 JPEG | 低,稳定 |
| 主码流(`mode=ffmpeg`) | RTSP → ffmpeg 解码/缩放 → 编码 JPEG | 取决于传输方式 |
主码流**不能走 TCP**:RTP over TCP 一旦有排队(设备发送缓冲、交换队列),延迟只会越堆越高、
而且永远不会自己追回来(TCP 不丢帧)。所以实时预览的 ffmpeg 参数固定为:
- 传输 `-rtsp_transport udp`(丢包宁可丢帧,不排队;4 秒还收不到帧会**自动回退 TCP**,
因为部分网络禁 UDP,不能让用户看不了画面);
- `-analyzeduration 0 -max_delay 0 -reorder_queue_size 0 -avioflags direct -fflags nobuffer -flags low_delay -fps_mode passthrough`
(不分析流、不攒包、输出侧不补帧);
- 回放(`OpenUrl` 的 `lowLatency=false`)**保持 TCP**:回放靠时间戳对齐,丢包会算错延迟。
排查用日志(`logs\log_日期.txt`):
- `ffmpeg 已启动:... UDP` / `TCP` —— 实际用的传输方式;
- `[ffmpeg] 首帧到达:... 用时 320ms(UDP)` —— 首帧耗时;
- `[ffmpeg] UDP 收不到帧,回退 TCP` —— 该网络不通 UDP。
### 为什么没有单独的「探活 / health」接口
探活通过 ≠ 真正查询时软件还在(用户可能中途退出了),两次请求之间状态会变。

View File

@ -84,7 +84,7 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
public int Open(string host, int rtspPort, string userName, string password, string streamId, int width = 1280, int fps = 25, int quality = 6)
{
var url = BuildRtspUrl(host, rtspPort, userName, password, streamId);
return OpenUrl(url, $"{host}:{rtspPort}|{streamId}", width, fps, quality);
return OpenUrl(url, $"{host}:{rtspPort}|{streamId}", width, fps, quality, lowLatency: true);
}
/// <summary>
@ -92,7 +92,12 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
///
/// <paramref name="keyPrefix"/> 是复用键前缀,**不能含密码**(地址里有账号密码)。
/// </summary>
public int OpenUrl(string url, string keyPrefix, int width = 1280, int fps = 25, int quality = 6)
/// <param name="lowLatency">
/// 实时预览用:RTP 走 **UDP**(TCP 一旦排队延迟只会越堆越高)+ 关掉流分析/重排缓冲;
/// UDP 4 秒收不到帧会自动回退 TCP(部分网络禁 UDP,不能因此看不了画面)。
/// 回放**不要**开:回放靠时间戳对齐,丢包/丢帧会算错延迟。
/// </param>
public int OpenUrl(string url, string keyPrefix, int width = 1280, int fps = 25, int quality = 6, bool lowLatency = false)
{
if (!IsAvailable)
{
@ -101,7 +106,9 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
"也可以设置环境变量 YUNCANG_FFMPEG 指定 ffmpeg.exe,或改用「满帧率窗口」看主码流。");
}
var key = $"{keyPrefix}|{width}|{fps}|{quality}";
var key = lowLatency
? $"{keyPrefix}|{width}|{fps}|{quality}|ll"
: $"{keyPrefix}|{width}|{fps}|{quality}";
lock (_gate)
{
@ -119,13 +126,14 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
Key = key,
Description = key,
RefCount = 1,
LowLatency = lowLatency,
};
StartProcess(stream, url, width, fps, quality);
StartProcess(stream, url, width, fps, quality, lowLatency);
_streams[handle] = stream;
_byKey[key] = handle;
AppLog.Write($"ffmpeg 已启动:{key}({width} 宽,{fps}fps,q={quality})handle={handle}");
AppLog.Write($"ffmpeg 已启动:{key}({width} 宽,{fps}fps,q={quality},{stream.Transport.ToUpperInvariant()})handle={handle}");
return handle;
}
}
@ -202,25 +210,45 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
return $"rtsp://{Uri.EscapeDataString(userName)}:{Uri.EscapeDataString(password)}@{host}:{rtspPort}/Streaming/Channels/{streamId}";
}
private void StartProcess(FfmpegStream stream, string url, int width, int fps, int quality)
/// <summary>UDP 收不到帧时,等多久回退 TCP</summary>
private static readonly TimeSpan UdpFallbackDelay = TimeSpan.FromSeconds(4);
private void StartProcess(FfmpegStream stream, string url, int width, int fps, int quality, bool lowLatency)
{
stream.Transport = lowLatency ? "udp" : "tcp";
var scale = fps is > 0 and < 25
? $"scale={width}:-2,fps={fps}"
: $"scale={width}:-2";
// 低延迟参数(实测:不关流分析/重排,首帧和稳态都会多出几百毫秒):
// -analyzeduration 0 不花时间分析流
// -max_delay / -reorder_queue_size 0 不为了“凑齐顺序”而攒包(实时画面宁可丢帧)
// -fflags nobuffer 解码器不预读
// -fps_mode passthrough 不在输出侧重复帧凑固定帧率
var latencyArgs = lowLatency
? new[] { "-analyzeduration", "0", "-max_delay", "0", "-reorder_queue_size", "0", "-avioflags", "direct" }
: Array.Empty<string>();
var args = string.Join(' ',
"-nostdin",
"-loglevel", "error",
"-rtsp_transport", "tcp",
"-fflags", "nobuffer",
"-flags", "low_delay",
"-i", Quote(url),
"-vf", Quote(scale),
"-f", "mjpeg",
"-q:v", quality.ToString(),
"-an",
"-flush_packets", "1",
"pipe:1");
new[] { "-nostdin", "-loglevel", "error", "-rtsp_transport", stream.Transport }
.Concat(latencyArgs)
.Concat(new[]
{
"-fflags", "nobuffer",
"-flags", "low_delay",
"-i", Quote(url),
"-vf", Quote(scale),
})
.Concat(lowLatency ? new[] { "-fps_mode", "passthrough" } : Array.Empty<string>())
.Concat(new[]
{
"-f", "mjpeg",
"-q:v", quality.ToString(),
"-an",
"-flush_packets", "1",
"pipe:1",
}));
var psi = new ProcessStartInfo
{
@ -235,6 +263,7 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
var process = new Process { StartInfo = psi, EnableRaisingEvents = true };
stream.Process = process;
stream.StartedAtTicks = Environment.TickCount64;
if (!process.Start())
{
@ -259,12 +288,45 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
});
// stdout:按 JPEG 的 FFD8…FFD9 切帧
Task.Run(() => PumpFrames(stream));
Task.Run(() => PumpFrames(stream, process));
// 低延迟默认走 UDP:部分网络/设备禁 UDP,4 秒还没出帧就回退 TCP(不能让用户看不了画面)
if (lowLatency && stream.Transport == "udp") ScheduleUdpFallback(stream, url, width, fps, quality);
}
private static void PumpFrames(FfmpegStream stream)
/// <summary>UDP 收不到帧就杀掉进程、改用 TCP 重开一次(只重开一次)</summary>
private void ScheduleUdpFallback(FfmpegStream stream, string url, int width, int fps, int quality)
{
Task.Run(async () =>
{
try
{
await Task.Delay(UdpFallbackDelay).ConfigureAwait(false);
if (stream.Disposed || stream.FramesReceived > 0) return;
lock (stream.RestartGate)
{
// 再查一次:可能在等锁的这会儿出帧了
if (stream.Disposed || stream.FramesReceived > 0) return;
AppLog.Write($"[ffmpeg] UDP 收不到帧,回退 TCP:{stream.Description}");
try { if (stream.Process is { HasExited: false }) stream.Process.Kill(true); } catch { /* 忽略 */ }
try { stream.Process?.Dispose(); } catch { /* 忽略 */ }
stream.Process = null;
StartProcess(stream, url, width, fps, quality, lowLatency: false);
}
}
catch (Exception ex)
{
AppLog.Write($"[ffmpeg] 回退 TCP 失败:{ex.Message}");
}
});
}
private static void PumpFrames(FfmpegStream stream, Process process)
{
var process = stream.Process!;
var buffer = new List<byte>(256 * 1024);
var chunk = new byte[64 * 1024];
@ -354,20 +416,47 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
public Process? Process { get; set; }
public string? LastError { get; set; }
/// <summary>实时预览(UDP 优先 + 低延迟参数)</summary>
public bool LowLatency { get; init; }
/// <summary>当前进程用的 RTP 传输方式:udp / tcp</summary>
public string Transport { get; set; } = "tcp";
/// <summary>当前进程启动时刻(TickCount64,用来看首帧要多久)</summary>
public long StartedAtTicks { get; set; }
/// <summary>已收到的帧数(UDP 回退 TCP 靠它判断“到底出没出画面”)</summary>
public long FramesReceived { get; private set; }
/// <summary>已关闭(回退任务不能再把进程拉起来)</summary>
public bool Disposed { get; private set; }
/// <summary>串行化“回退重开”</summary>
public object RestartGate { get; } = new();
/// <summary>
/// 新帧入队:覆盖「最新一帧」(背压),同时**逐帧通知订阅者**(回放对齐要每一帧)
/// </summary>
public void Enqueue(byte[] frame)
{
Action<byte[]>[] snapshot;
bool first;
lock (_sync)
{
_latest = frame;
_version++;
FramesReceived++;
first = FramesReceived == 1;
snapshot = _subscribers.Count == 0 ? Array.Empty<Action<byte[]>>() : _subscribers.ToArray();
}
if (first)
{
var cost = StartedAtTicks > 0 ? Environment.TickCount64 - StartedAtTicks : -1;
AppLog.Write($"[ffmpeg] 首帧到达:{Description} 用时 {cost}ms({Transport.ToUpperInvariant()})");
}
// 回调在 ffmpeg 读线程上:只允许做入队这类快操作
foreach (var handler in snapshot)
{
@ -429,6 +518,8 @@ public sealed class HikFfmpegService : IDisposable
public void Terminate()
{
Disposed = true;
try
{
if (Process is { HasExited: false })